Skip to content

The Power of Tangible Media in Rebuilding Customer Trust

Article - 8 Min. Read

In today’s crowded digital landscape, earning trust can be harder than ever. See how direct mail can help brands strengthen relationships among increasingly selective and skeptical consumers.

Share this article

Share this article on LinkedIn Copy this link to clipboard https://www.uspsdelivers.com/tangible-media-rebuild-customer-trust/

Share this article

Share this article on LinkedIn Copy this link to clipboard https://www.uspsdelivers.com/tangible-media-rebuild-customer-trust/
A view from inside a mailbox of woman peering in and grabbing her mail.

Brands have more opportunities to engage customers than ever before. However, earning and maintaining their trust has become increasingly difficult. As artificial intelligence (AI) reshapes the marketing landscape, digital channels grow more crowded, and concerns around data privacy and authenticity continue to rise. As such, marketers are rethinking what it takes to build trust.

Top Insights: At a Glance

  • Privacy concerns, the rise of AI and a crowded digital landscape—with increasingly complex customer journeys—have made it harder for consumers to know whom to trust.
  • Direct mail can help brands build confidence and earn trust, offering a uniquely tangible experience that can feel more intentional, authentic and personal than digital.
  • By using direct mail to forge trust across the entire customer journey and integrating it into a larger omnichannel strategy, brands strengthen customer relationships while complementing digital efforts.

Recognizing the decline in consumer trust, the United States Postal Service (USPS), along with Winterberry Group, has examined evolving customer attitudes and explored how brands are adapting.

The resulting 2026 white paper from Winterberry Group found that marketers are responding by prioritizing channels that deliver clear, credible experiences as well as strengthening omnichannel strategies that create consistent customer experiences across touchpoints.[1] The rapid expansion of AI has made these priorities more urgent as brands aim to deliver more personal, relevant experiences without compromising consumer confidence.

Together, these trends point to a broader shift in marketing. Trust is no longer just a nice-to-have campaign outcome—it’s now a key driver of long‑term success.

The Growing Trust Gap in Digital Marketing

Customer journeys have become increasingly fluid and complex. Consumers may interact with brands across multiple touchpoints spanning several different channels; someone may open a personalized marketing email, ignore follow‑up paid ads, then re‑engage later via social. While these pathways create ample opportunities for engagement, they also increase the risk of overwhelming customers. In a crowded marketing landscape, every interaction has the potential to erode or strengthen trust.

Advances in technology have also made it easier than ever to understand and create more targeted experiences. AI, for example, allows marketers to analyze vast datasets, uncover valuable insights and create tailored experiences at scale—but it’s also made some consumers wary. In fact, 70% of consumers reported being worried about data privacy and security, up from 60% the previous year.[2] Responding to these concerns with transparency and openness can help brands strengthen customer confidence.

Ultimately, the challenge has shifted from merely reaching consumers to creating experiences that earn their trust.

From Reach to Trust: Why Direct Mail Matters More Than Ever

As consumers become more cautious about their digital interactions, marketers are looking beyond frequency and personalization to consider not only what they communicate, but the broader experience they create around it.

Direct mail offers something increasingly valuable: a tangible, real‑world touchpoint that feels intentional and credible—and can shape how consumers perceive your brand. Thirty‑six percent of consumers trust direct mail more than online ads,[3] and 49% of consumers view brands that send direct mail as more credible than those that don’t.[4]

Build Credibility with Tangible Experiences

With digital skepticism on the rise, physical media offers a different kind of brand interaction—one that is intentional and authentic. While digital serves an essential role, relying on it alone can fatigue customers when interactions feel automated and transactional. With repeated targeting and retargeting, even highly relevant messages can begin to feel impersonal—or even intrusive.

A mailpiece creates a different kind of interaction through a direct, physical experience. Its origin is easily identifiable, and its purpose is less ambiguous than that of digital ads. Incorporating special textures, inks, varnishes and other elements into a mailpiece can also signal a higher level of investment and care, encouraging recipients to spend more time with it.

As digital marketing becomes increasingly automated and AI continues to blur the line between machine‑ and human‑created content, real‑world channels will continue to increase in value. Seventy‑four percent of consumers familiar with or experimenting with generative artificial intelligence (GenAI) say its growing popularity makes it harder to trust what they see online.[5]

By creating focused moments of engagement, direct mail can significantly improve brand recall. Research conducted by Jonathan Zhang, Ph.D. found that physical materials, such as direct mail, require 21% less cognitive effort to process than digital media yet generate stronger emotional responses and higher memory retention.[6]

These memorable, authentic experiences can support downstream digital engagement and strengthen customer relationships throughout the customer journey.

Forge Trust Across the Customer Journey

Customer trust isn’t forged through a single interaction or touchpoint; it must be earned over time through consistent, credible experiences. Direct mail can be a powerful performance channel, with its value extending far beyond driving immediate action.

The same qualities that make mail so effective at capturing attention and prompting response also make it valuable for building trust over time. Whether raising general awareness, nurturing consideration or building confidence at key decision points, direct mail can help create meaningful interactions along the path to purchase.

While digital‑only efforts may compete for attention in crowded feeds or get filtered in overloaded inboxes, mail creates a dedicated brand touchpoint. An intentional, physical experience like this creates space for recipients to engage with the mailpiece, build familiarity and develop confidence as they move through the customer journey.

This engagement can also drive action across other channels, creating a more connected omnichannel experience.

Integrate Direct Mail Into a Larger Omnichannel Strategy

Effective marketing depends on more than just reaching customers across multiple channels. It requires a seamless, coordinated experience that reinforces trust.

As a tangible channel, direct mail can strengthen campaigns by complementing digital efforts, reinforcing brand credibility and creating more cohesive customer experiences. When physical and digital touchpoints work together, brands can deliver more consistent interactions that build familiarity and trust over time.

A successful omnichannel strategy relies on actionable data and insights. As marketers continue to invest in AI, automation and advanced analytics tools, they’re better able to understand customer behavior, coordinate channels and personalize content. Winterberry Group found that nearly 96% of marketers are using or testing AI to support direct mail programs, with 93% saying those efforts deliver moderate or significant value.[7] The same technologies contributing to digital skepticism are also helping marketers create more connected, relevant omnichannel experiences.

Frequently Asked Questions

How is AI affecting consumer trust in marketing?

How can direct mail help brands build customer trust?

Why can direct mail feel more credible than digital advertising?

How can brands build trust across the customer journey?

How can brands combine direct mail with digital marketing to build trust?

Why do tangible, offline brand experiences matter in omnichannel marketing?

Key Takeaway

In a marketing landscape defined by speed, scale and increasing automation, it’s easier for brands to connect with customers across a range of channels and formats. But as digital experiences become more tailored yet less personal, earning trust has become a key differentiator.

As consumers become more selective about the brands they engage with, marketers must consider not just what they’re communicating, but how they’re delivering it. By creating tangible, credible experiences that encourage engagement, direct mail can help brands strengthen customer relationships throughout the customer journey while complementing digital efforts as part of a well‑connected omnichannel strategy.

Footnotes

  1. [1]“Delivering Performance in the Era of AI: Technology, Data and New Opportunities to Unlock Omnichannel Success,” Winterberry Group, June 2026.
  2. [2]Steve Fineberg, Susanne Hupfer, Jeff Loucks, Michael Steinhart and Sayantani Mazumder, “In the gen AI economy, consumers want innovation they can trust,” Deloitte, Sept. 25, 2025.
  3. [3]“State of Direct Mail 2026: Consumer Insights Edition,” Lob, 2026.
  4. [4]“State of Direct Mail 2025: Consumer Insights Edition,” Lob, 2025.
  5. [5]Steve Fineberg, Susanne Hupfer, Jeff Loucks, Michael Steinhart and Sayantani Mazumder, “In the gen AI economy, consumers want innovation they can trust,” Deloitte, Sept. 25, 2025.
  6. [6]“Maximizing Marketing Impact: Why Direct Mail Deserves a Place in Every Multichannel Strategy,” Dr. Jonathan Zhang, USPS Delivers, 2025.
  7. [7]“Delivering Performance in the Era of AI: Technology, Data and New Opportunities to Unlock Omnichannel Success,” Winterberry Group, June 2026.
  8. [8]QR Code is a registered trademark of DENSO WAVE INCORPORATED.

Related Content